Folheando jornais: uma janela aberta para as representações de ciência e tecnologia na imprensa periódica portuguesa (1900-1926)

2008-2011

Coordenação CIUHCT

Ana Simões

Financiamento

FCT PTDC/HCT/68210/2006

Período

2008 - 2011

Sobre o projecto (Inglês)


Summary

Popularization of science and technology is an established field within the history of science and technology. In the past years, though, the historiography of science popularization is undergoing a crisis. The received view of popular science as a downgraded version of science for lay-consumers does not hold any more. Proposals for critical revisions of the dichotomies built in the characterization of popular science, such as the dichotomy between production and consumption, creativity and passive reception, experts and lay audiences are open for discussion.

This project is an innovative contribution to the field both at the international and national level: it uses new primary sources to provide a fresh look at popularization of science and technology in the European periphery, a largely undervalued sub-field within the larger area of popularization of science and technology. At the theoretical level, the project will contribute to help re-conceptualize the historiographical category of science popularization.

In this project we aim at analyzing the representations of science and technology stemming from the Portuguese generalist press covering a period from the end of the monarchy to the end of the first Republic.

Newspapers were chosen on the basis of their broad ideological scope and geographical locations. Such is the case of Diário de Notícias (founded 1865), Comércio do Porto (f. 1854) and Diário dos Açores (f. 1870). We will further consider the suitability of including additionally culturally oriented newspapers issued in each of the selected cities. In the beginning of the 20th century, both the Oporto's and Azores' newspapers were part of Portuguese mainstream press, which was politically engaged in a double sense, either by aligning itself with a particular political party, or by making politics its main theme: the Oporto newspaper was a prestigious one of wide circulation and republican leanings; and the islander newspaper represented a sector of the monarchical intelligentsia linked to the Partido Progressista (Progressive Party).

Methodology

Methodologically we will opt for a comprehensive (systematic and extremely time-consuming) survey of the totality of news issued in all newspapers selected during the whole period under study. This option will enable a quantitative approach and hence more reliable conclusions. Based on the senior members' preliminary experience each news will be classified according to a classificatory grid.

Classification grid (general):

  • Articles
    • Opinion:
    • News:
    • Advertisments
    • Dramatisation
  • Author (if stated)
  • Positioning
  • Themes


Major thematic areas:

  • Introduction of new technologies;
  • Innovations in science;
  • Hygiene, health and medicine;
  • Science and natural phenomena;
  • Science and religion;
  • Women, gender and science;
  • Science in the local public arena.

In order to handle the huge amount of news surveyed, each will be summarized or transcribed (partially or integrally) or scanned according to relevance. An on-line database will be created to house entries for each of the news.

Outcomes


The main objective of this project is to analyze public perceptions of science and technology in a country of the European periphery with an extreme high illiteracy rate during the first decades of the 20th century by using a comparative method based on the contrast of news issued in newspapers of different political orientations and geographical provenance. 

At the national level, it aims at contributing to unveil the role and functions of science in a peripheral country during a period which voiced consistently an ideology in which science played a crucial role, to assess differences between ideological aims, the rhetoric of scientism, daily practices and their outcomes by using a bottom-up methodology. At the international level, it aims at contributing to prepare the ground for a comparative study of the views on science and technology as voiced in newspapers at the dawn of the 20th century in different countries of the European peripheries - Greece, Spain and Portugal. This is a project integrated in one of the research lines pushed forward by the international STEP group (Science and Technology in the European Peripheries, see http://www.cc.uoa.gr/step; http://www.uv.es/comic/step5 ).

Research Team

Members Publications


Bibliography

  • d'Andrea, Luciano, A.Declich, "The sociological nature of science communication," Journal of Science Communication 4(2005), 1-9. [pdf]
  • Andrews, J.T., Science for the Masses. The Bolshevik state, public science, and the popular imagination in Soviet Russia, 1917-1934 (Texas: A& M Univ Press, ????) [pdf]
  • Aspinall, A. "The Circulation of Newspapers in the Early Nineteenth Century." Review of English Studies 22 (1946): 29-43. [pdf]
  • Barton, Ruth. "Just before 'Nature'. The Purposes of Sciences and the Purposes of Popularisation in Some English Popular Science Journals of the 1860s." Annals of science 55 (1998): 1-33. [pdf]
  • Bauer, Martin W.; Bucchi, Massimiano, ed. Journalism, Science and Society: Science Communication News and Public Relations. London: Routledge, 2006.
    • "Introduction and a guidance for the reader" [pdf] ;
    • Part I "The changing scenarios of science communication." [pdf]
  • Bauer, Martin W.; Petkova Kristina; Boyadjieva Pepka. "Long-Term Trends in the Public Representation of Science Across the 'Iron Curtain": 1945-1995." Social Studies of Science 36, no. 1 (2006): 99-131. [pdf]
  • Bauer, Martin W.; Schoon, Ingrid. "Mapping Variety in Public Understanding of Science." Public Understanding of Science 2 (1993): 141-55. [pdf]
  • Beder, S., M. Shortland, "Siting a hazardous waste facility: the tangled web of risk communication," Public Understanding of Science, 1 (1992), 139-160. [pdf]
  • Behari Lal, "Popularization of Science through News." Philosophy of Science 12, no. 2 (1945): 41-44. [pdf]
  • Bensaude-Vincent, B. "A Genealogy of the Increasing Gap between Science and the Public." Public Understanding of Science 10 (2001): 99. [pdf]
  • Bowler, Peter. "Experts and Publishers: Writing Popular Science in Early Twentieth-Century Britain, Writing Popular History of Science Now." British Journal for the history of science 39 (2006): 159-87. [pdf]
  • P. Brenni, "19th century instruments advertising," in ? [pdf]
  • Broks, P. Media Science before the Great War. Basingstoke: MacMillan, 1996. [pdf]
  • Broks, Peter. "Science, Media and Culture: British Magazines, 1890-1914." Public Understanding of Science 2 (1993): 123-39. [pdf]
  • T. Broman, "The Habermasian public sphere and 'science in the Enlightenment'", History of Science, 36 (1998), 123-149. [pdf]
  • Bucchi, Massimiano. Science and the Media. Alternatives Routes in Scientific Communication. London and New York: Rootledge, 2004.
    • "Introduction", 1-14 [pdf] and
    • "When scientists turn to the public", 15-32. [pdf]
  • Bucchi, Massimiano; Mazzolini, Renato G. "Big Science, Little News: Science Coverage in the Italian Daily Press, 1964-1997." Public Understanding of Science 12 (2003): 7-24. [pdf]
  • Cantor, G. et al., ed. Science in the Nineteenth Century Periodical: Reading the Magazine of Nature. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2004.
    • Dawson, Noakes, Topham, "Introduction" [pdf],
    • Topham, "The mirror of literature, amusement and instruction and cheap miscellanies in early 19th century Britain," 37-66 [pdf],
    • Dawson, "The Review of Reviews and the new journalism in late-Victorian Britain," 172-195 [pdf],
    • Cantor, "Scientific biography in the periodical press," 216-237 [pdf],
    • Gooday," Profit and prophecy: electricity in the late-Victorian periodical", 238-254. [pdf]
    • Notes [pdf]
  • Cantor, G.; Shuttleworth, Sally, ed. Science Serialised; Representations of the Sciences in Nineteenth-Century Periodicals. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 2004.
    • Introduction [pdf],
    • Topham, "Science, natural theology, and the practice of Christian piety in early 19th century religious magazines," 37-66 [pdf],
    • Small, "Science, liberalism and the ethics of belief: the Contemporary Review in 1877", 239-57 [pdf],
    • Ritvo, "Understanding audiences and misunderstanding audiences: some publics for science", 331-49. [pdf]
  • Cantor, G.; Shuttleworth, Sally; Topham, Jonathan. "Representations of Science in the 19th-Century Periodical Press." Interdisciplinary Science Reviews 28 (2003): 161-68. [pdf]
  • Christidou, Vasilia; Dimopoulos Kostas, Koulaidis Vasilis. "Constructing Social Representations of Science and Technology: The Role of Metaphors in the Press and the Popular Scientific Magazines." Public Understanding of Science 13 (2004): 347-62. [pdf]
  • Clemens, Elisabeth S. "Of Asteroids and Dinosaurs: The Role of the Press in the Shaping of Scientific Debate." Social Studies of Science 16, no. 3 (1989): 421-56. [pdf]
  • Collins, Harry. "Certainty and the Public Understanding of Science: Science on Television." Social Studies of Science 17, no. 4 (1987): 689-713. [pdf]
  • Cook, Guy; Robbins, Peter T; Pieri, Elisa. "'Words of Mass Destruction': British Newspaper Coverage of the Generically Modified Food Debate, Expert and Non-Expert Reactions." Public Understanding of Science 15 (2006): 5-29. [pdf]
  • Cooter, R., Pumphrey, S. "Separate Spheres and Public Places: Reflexions on the History of Science Popularisation and Science in Popular Culture." History of Science 32 (1994): 237-67. [pdf]
  • Cotkin, G. "The Socialist Popularization of Science in America, 1901 to the First World War." History of Education Quarterly 24, no. 2 (1984): 201-14. [pdf]
  • Curtis, Ron. "Narrative Form and Normative Force: Baconian Story-Telling in Popular Science." Social Studies of Science 24, no. 3 (1994): 419-61. [pdf]
  • Dimopoulos, K., Koulaidis, V. "The Socio-Epistemic Constitution of Science and Technology in the Greek Press: An Analysis of Its Presentation." Public Understanding of Science (2002): 225-41. [pdf]
  • Dunwoody, Sharon; Peters, Hans Peter. "Mass Media Coverage of Technological and Environmental Risks: A Survey of Research in the United States and Germany." Public Understanding of Science 1 (1992): 199-230. [pdf]
  • Durant, John, et. Al. . ''Public understanding of science in Britain: the role of medicine in the popular representation of science'', Public Understanding of Science, 1 (????), 161-182. [pdf]
  • Einsiedel, Edna F. "Framing Science and Technology." Public Understanding of Science 1(1992): 89-101. [pdf]
  • Eliot, S.. "Some Trends in British Book Production, 1800-1919." In Literature in the Marketplace: Nineteenth-Century British Publishing and Reading Practices, edited by J.O.; Patten, Jordan, R.L., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995, 19-43.
  • Ellegård, A. Darwin and the General Reader: The Reception of Darwin's Theory of Evolution in the British Periodical Press, 1859-1872. Chicago; London: Chicago University Press, 1990. [pdf] [pdf] [pdf] [pdf]
  • Evans, W., "Bibliography," Public Understanding of Science 10 (2001), 153-5. [pdf]
  • Franck, F., "Sanity, scientism, and 'salvation'", Bulletin of Science, Technology and Society, 13 (1993), 15-19. [pdf]
  • Gamson, William, Modigliani, Andre, "Media discourse and public opinion on nuclear power: a constructionist approach". The American Journal of Sociology, 95/1 (1989), 1-37. [pdf]
  • Golinski, J. Science as Public Culture: Chemistry and Enlightenment in Britain, 1760-1820. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1992.
  • Gross, Alan G. . The rhetoric of science. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1986.
  • Hagendijk, Rod; Meeus Jan. "Blind Faith: Fact, Fiction and Fraud in Public Controversy over Science." Public Understanding of Science 2 (1993): 391-415. [pdf]
  • Hansen, A., "Journalistic practices and science reporting in the British Press," Public Understanding of Science 3 (1994), 111-34. [pdf]
  • Henson, Louise, G. Cantor, G.Dawson, R. Noakes, S. Shuttleworth, J.R.Topham. Culture and Science in the 19th Century Press. Aldershot: Ashgate, 2004.
  • Hilgartner, Stephen. . 1990. ''The Dominant View of Popularization: Conceptual Problems, Political Uses'', Social Studies of Science, 20 (1990), 519-539. [pdf]
  • Hilgartner, Stephen y Bosk, Charles. "The rise and fall of social problems: A public arenas model". The American Journal of Sociology, 94/1 (1988), 53-78. [pdf]
  • Holton, Gerald. "How to Think About the 'Anti-Science' Phenomenon." Public Understanding of Science 1 (1992): 103-28. [pdf]
  • Holton, G., "Can science be at the center of modern culture?", Public Understanding of Science 2 (1993), 291-305. [pdf]
  • Hornig, S., "Reading risk: public response to print media accounts of technological risks," Public Understanding of Science 2 (1993), 95-109. [pdf]
  • Hüppauf, P. Weingart, eds., Science Images and Popular Images of the Sciences (NY: Routledge, 2008). [pdf]
    • Hüppauf, P. Weingart, "Introduction: images in and of science, " 3-31; [pdf]
    • S. Nikolow, L. Bluma, "Science images between scientific fields and the public sphere. A historiographical survey," 33-51; [pdf]
    • B. Clarke, "The self-referential scientist. Narrative, media and the metamorphosis of Cronenberg's The Fly," 301-322. [pdf]
  • Hyden Fiona and King Chris, "What the papers say : science coverage by UK national newspapers", School science review, 88 (2006), 81-84. [pdf]
  • J. L. M. , Speaking of Science: Science and the Press: Communicating with the Public, Science, New Series, 193 (4248) (Jul. 9, 1976), 136. [pdf]
  • Jurdant, Baudoin. ''Popularization of science as the autobiography of science'', Public Understanding of Science, 2 (1993), 365-373. [pdf]
  • Knight, D., Public Understanding of Science. A history of communication of scientific ideas (London: Routledge, 2006).
    • Introduction, [pdf]
    • "Picturing science," [pdf]
    • "Display, [pdf]
    • "Promoters and popularizers." [pdf]
  • LaFollette, Marcel Chotkowski, Review:Selling Science: How the Press Covers Science and Technology by Dorothy Nelkin, Isis, 78 ( 4) (Dec. 1987), 650-652. [pdf]
  • Lederer, Susan E., Rogers, Naomi. "Media". In Cooter, Roger y Pickston, John (eds). Medicine in the twentieth century. Amsterdam: Harwood Academic Publishers, pp. 487-502.
  • Lewenstein, Bruce V. "Was There Really a Popular Science "Boom"?" Science, Technology and Human Values 12( 2) (1987), 29-41. [pdf]
  • Lewis, Elton. "Einstein, General Relativity, and the German Press, 1919-1920." ISIS 77(1), (1986), 95-103. [pdf]
  • Limoges, C., "Expert knowledge and decision making in controversy contexts," Public Understanding of Science 2 (1993), 417-26. [pdf]
  • Lindley, E.H.; Bryan, Wm. L. "Science in the Daily Press", Science, 11 (263), (1900), 74. [pdf]
  • Lynn, M.R. "Dividing the Enlightenment: Public Opinion and Popular Science in Old Regime France." ISIS 92 (2001), 34-54. [pdf]
  • Macdonald, S., R. Silvertone, "Science on display: the representation of scientific controversy in museum exhibitions," Public Understanding of Science 1 (1992), 69-87. [pdf]
  • Malone, R.; Boyd E.; Bero, L.A. "Science in the news: Journalist's Constructions of Passive Smoking as a Social Problem", Social Studies of Science 30/5 (2000), 713-735. [pdf]
  • Massarani, B Buys, LH Amorim, F Veneu, "Science Journalism in Latin America: A case study of seven newspapers in the region", Journal of Science Communication, 2005. Also in Portuguese. [pdf]
  • McLaughlin-Jenkins. "Common Knowledge: Science and the Late Victorian Working-Class Press." History of Science 39 (2001): 445-65. [pdf]
  • McRae, M.W. (ed). The Literature of Science: Perspectives on Popular Scientific Writing. Athens: University of Georgia Press, 1993.
    • Introduction [pdf]
    • D. Russell, "Popularization and the challenge to science-centrism in the 1930s," 37-53; [pdf]
    • B. Pegg, "Nature and nation in popular scientific narratives of polar explorations," 213-229; [pdf]
    • D.A. Stone, "Omni meets Feynman: the interaction between popular and scientific cultures," 291-310. [pdf]
  • A.J. Meadows, A.J. ed. The Development of Science Publishing in Europe, Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publishers, 1980.
    • Introduction [pdf]
    • R.M. MacLeod, "Evolutionism, Internationalism and Commercial Enterprise in Science: The International Scientific Series 1871-1910," 63-93; [pdf]
    • Sahw, "Patterns of journal publication in scientific natural history from 1800 to 1939," 149-176, [pdf]
    • MacLeod, Dixon, "Telling the people: science in the public press since WWII," 215-35. [pdf]
  • Miller, J.D., "Toward scientific understanding of the public understanding of science and technology," Public Understanding of Science 1 (1992), 23-6. [pdf]
  • Miller, S., "Public understanding of science at the crossroads," Public Understanding of Science 10 (2001), 115-20. [pdf]
  • Neidhardt, Friedhelm. "The Public as a Communication System." Public Understanding of Science 2 (1993): 339-50. [pdf]
  • Nelkin, Dorothy. Selling Science: How the Press Covers Science and Technology. New York: W.H. Freeman, 1995. [pdf]
  • Noakes, R. "Science in Mid-Victorian Punch." Endeavour 26 (2002): 92-96. [pdf]
  • Nowotny, Helga. "Socially Distributed Knowledge: Five Spaces for Science to Meet the Public." Public Understanding of Science 2 (1993): 307-19. [pdf]
  • Perlman, D. "Science and the mass media," Daedalus, ? (?), 207-22. [pdf]
  • Petkova K. and Boyadjieva P, "The image of the scientist and its functions", Public Understanding of Science, 3 (1994), 215-224. [pdf]
  • Pitrelli, N., F. Manzoli, B. Mantolli, "Science in advertising: uses and consumptions in the Italian Press," Public Understanding of Science 15 (2006), 207-220. [pdf]
  • Ritter Wm. E., "Science and the Newspapers", Science, New Series, 67(1733). (Mar. 16, 1928), 279-286. [pdf]
  • Rodgers, M., "The Hawking phenomenon," Public Understanding of Science 1 (1992), 231-4. [pdf]
  • Rose, J, "How historians stuffy reader response: or, what did Jo think of Bleak House?" In Literature in the Marketplace: Nineteenth-Century British Publishing and Reading Practices, edited by J.O.; Patten, Jordan, R.L., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995, 19-43. [pdf] Introduction [pdf]
  • Scanlon, E., E. Whitelegg, S. Yates, Communicating science. Contexts and Channels (London: Open University, 1999).
  • Secord, James. "Knowledge in Transit." ISIS 95 (2004): 654-72. [pdf]
  • Seppänen, Jane; Väliverronen, Esa. "Visualising Biodiversity: The Role of Photographs in Environmental Discourse." Science as Culture 12 (2003): 59-85. [pdf]
  • Shapin, Steven, ''Science and the Public'', in R. C. Olby; G. N. Cantor. (eds.), Companion to the History of Modern Science. London: Routledge, 1990, pp. 990-1007.
  • Shapin, Steven, ''Why the public ought to understand science-in-the-making'', Public Understanding of Science, 1 (1992), 27-30. [pdf]
  • Shea William R., "The History of Science and the Image of Science", Notes and Records of the Royal Society of London , 55/1 (Jan., 2001), 3-7. [pdf]
  • Sheets-Pyenson, S. "Popular Science Periodicals in Paris and London: The Emergence of a Low Scientific Culture, 1820-1875." Annals of science 42 (1985): 549-72. [pdf]
  • Shinn, T., Whitley, R. (ed.). Expository Science: Forms and Functions of Popularisation. Vol. 9, Sociology of the Sciences. Dordrecht: Reidel, 1985.
    • R. Whitley, "Knowledge producers and knowledge acquirers: popularization as a relation between scientific fields and their publics," 3-28; [pdf]
    • M. Biezunski,"Popularization and scientific controversy. The case of theory of relativity in France," 183-194; [pdf]
    • K. Bayertz, "Spreading the spirit of science. Social determinants of the Popularization of science in 19th century Germany," 209-227. [pdf]
  • Silverstone Roger, Communicating Science to the Public, Science, Technology, & Human Values, 16( 1) (Winter, 1991), 106-110. [pdf]
  • Simpson, C.R., "Nature as news: science reporting in the New York Times 1898 to 1983," The International Journal of Politics, Culture and Science 1(1987), 28-51. [pdf]
  • Solomon, J., "Reception and rejection of science knowledge: choice, style and home culture," Public Understanding of Science, 2 (1993), 111-21. [pdf]
  • Stahl, William A. "Venerating the Black Box: Magic in Media Discourse on Technology." Science, Technology and Human Values 20 (1995): 234-58. [pdf]
  • Thoman, Elizabeth. "Media, Technology and Culture." Bulletin of Science, Technology and Society 13 (1) (1993), 20-26. [pdf]
  • Topham, J.R., "Scientific publishing and the reading of science in 19th century Britain: a historiographical survey and guide to sources," Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science 31 (2001), 559-612. [pdf]
  • Topham, J.R., "Beyond the 'Common Context'. The production and reading of the Bridgewater Treatises," ISIS 89 (1998), 233-62. [pdf]
  • Turner, Frank M, ''Public Science in Britain. 1880 - 1919'', Isis, 71 (1980), 589-608. [pdf]
  • Yeo, R., Science in the Public Sphere. Natural Knowledge in British Culture 1800-1860 (Ashgate, 2001).
    • Contents [pdf]
    • "An idol of the market-place: Baconianism in the 19th century Britain," pp.? [pdf]
  • Ziadat, Adel A. "Early Reception of Einstein's Relativity in the Arab Periodical Press." Annals of science 51 (1994): 17-35. [pdf]
  • Ziman, J. "Public understanding of science," Science, Technology and Human Values, 16 (1991), 99-105. [pdf]